“It’s near the Campo de’ Fiori,” I said. My mouth awkwardly curved around the words, proper nouns that were much easier to rattle off when I was less self-conscious. I was twisted up in jet lag, still bitter about the mushy avocado toast I’d ingested two hours earlier. I grabbed Kathy by the elbow and directed her past outstretched arms and selfie sticks, down an alley lined with tacky trinket shops and chalkboard menus that advertised lasagna, French fries and hamburgers—in every language except Italian. My map said the Campo de’ Fiori was half a mile away, a distance that felt like crossing an ocean from where we stood, parked behind a pack of idling tourists wearing hockey jerseys. They debated which gelato shop to enter, as if each one offered something unique.
“There are so many people!” I shouted. I looked back at Kathy to get a response but she was head-down, eyes on her phone like a kid holding a treasure map. I took a deep breath and kept moving, desperate to find a restaurant I hadn’t seen in decades.
I’d never actually eaten there, either, but I could paint it for you if you asked. The space was full of buttery light and chocolate brown banquettes. They were plush, probably velvet. The waiters, in black tie, laid napkins in laps and placed gleaming silver cutlery on crisp white tablecloths. In college, Kathy and I spent our Wednesday nights right outside, biting into day-old pastries while we peered through the big glass window marked with proud gold letters. It had been a thrill standing there, unbothered by our plain jeans and bad haircuts and rollneck sweaters, a look more appropriate for a keg party than the savvy streets of Rome. Lilting language danced around us while we watched regal women in bright silk scarves and men in tweed sip red wine and eat spring vegetables, sole, cacio y pepe. They moved with a delicacy that came from breeding, not study. We were young then, not yet prone to piercing envy.
I kept my mouth shut. Mentioning this memory to Kathy was useless, and it was difficult enough finding a gap in the crowd. We squeezed by a group of gray-haired men with lanyards dangling from their wrinkled necks.
But, despite my irritation, I was determined to be excited. The new me, a hopeful one, would celebrate the glorious second half of life without my husband of twenty years. He’d claimed reinvention with appalling gusto, and I had to locate a different word. My therapist had called it a reset midway through our last appointment, and I hated her a little bit more. I’d wasted approximately three hundred fifty post-tax dollars on a term that made me feel flat and empty, like the life I was left with after Frank decided he wanted something else. After he decided, actually, that he didn’t want me.
Kathy was now in the lead, pulling my hand. We landed at the edge of the Piazza della Rotonda. I abruptly stopped.
“The Pantheon!” I pointed at the giant structure in front of us. Kathy looked up, smirked and returned to her phone.
“That restaurant’s only availability is at nine p.m.,” she said. “That won’t work.”
“Then let’s have a late lunch there,” I said, hoping she’d detect my pedantic tone. The cross-Atlantic flight had exposed a new Kathy, the suburban-housewife version who didn’t touch gluten, sugar, or any substance other than water after eight p.m. She’d carried on a cooler bag full of pills, powders and gels meant to extend her life, which she seemed to spend complaining and scrolling through photos of other people’s vacations. By the time we’d made it through customs and retrieved two large rolling bags she’d insisted on checking, I was certain I didn’t like this new version of Kathy.
She nodded, half-there, eyes eating up the screen. I took that as a yes.
She furiously typed on her phone and sighed. Her nails were painted light purple, and a powdery smell lingered around her body like a force field. I coughed.
“Matt’s tennis coach is such an idiot. I told him I was going away!” Kathy tapped some more. The little c’s on the edges of her forehead, the only bits that moved, attempted to reach her hairline. Watching her try to frown made me miss our past lives even more.
The Pantheon distracted me from what could become an argument. I was being good, indulging Kathy’s misunderstanding that this trip across the Atlantic Ocean was about her and her service providers. I’d exercised restraint during my marriage, too. Maybe this would be different.
I took some pleasure in the fun facts I remembered. The Pantheon is almost 2,000 years old. Raphael is buried there. The dome’s height is the same as its diameter and, as a result, it’s a perfect sphere. When I was younger, I’d marveled at the Pantheon’s magnificence, not its symmetry.
The columns weigh over sixty tons each. I doubted this when our teacher told us. It seemed impossible for humans to carry that much weight.
What I wanted to remember the most, though, was beyond my grasp. It was a feeling I’d been too young to recognize. I was confident that life would work out, not yet tethered to knowing it wouldn’t.
We walked a bit further and stopped a few yards away from an outdoor café, lined with pink linen-covered tables. People drank cappuccino and chatted, their voices like birdsong. I saw her, me, sipping an espresso, putting thoughts on paper. My chest tightened as I wondered where all those letters had gone. Years earlier, I’d found one in my mother’s closet and stuffed it inside my planner before it got swept up with all the other dusty things that ended up in a landfill. We had been too keen to throw stuff out, not knowing that grief has its own agenda. It stays put no matter what you do. I’d covered both sides of my baby blue stationery with pretty cursive words that were foreign to me now: apse, portico, aedicule. My need to please the reader was all over the page. If Frank had kept any of my letters and postcards, I was sure his new girlfriend had burnt them in some kind of cleansing ritual. But this had been me.
“Were you in my art history class? This was the first building we toured,” I said, nodding at the Pantheon, in case Kathy had forgotten where we were. I tried to remember what my professor looked like, but all that came to me was a tan trench coat and a brown leather shoulder bag overflowing with papers. She was inconsequential, just another adult who told me when to listen and what to remember.
“It’s been in use for thousands of years,” I said. “That’s why it hasn’t crumbled.” But my words dissolved in the piazza, wasted.
“I have to coordinate one thing with the SAT tutor and then I can focus,” Kathy said. “No one tells you that getting your kid into college is a full-time job!” She exhaled, loudly, to reinforce my lack of understanding in this area. Frank and I never had children. It was a choice, the least of my regrets, especially now, watching Kathy wrap every minute of her life around hers like soft bunting. She quickly glanced at the Pantheon, perhaps realizing there was an Instagram opportunity here.
“Ohmygod! I remember! The hole at the top was, like, a big deal. It helped the whole thing stay together.” She gave me a look one might describe as vaguely mischievous. “Let’s take a pic inside, staring down so that the sun’s reflection is, like, right at our feet!”
I bit the inside of my cheek and tried again.
“We used to look up all the time,” I said.
I tilted my face up to the soft March sunlight. The sounds around us became a pastel drawing: tiny cups clinking, motorbikes zipping past, an Italian tour guide speaking with an undulating cadence, like she was unraveling a gift’s ribbon. And she was. I commended myself for being present, for demonstrating this to Kathy.
“I look up every day, Jane,” she said with a tilt of the head. No wonder her children were such assholes, I thought. Her phone buzzed. She put her readers back on and furiously typed like a warrior who’d been thrown back into battle.
I opened my mouth for rebuttal but stopped myself. I was a dam that might burst any minute. I imagined Kathy drowning, right there, under a deluge of water that smacked against the massive doors of the Pantheon in a giant wave. That would be something.
Look up. Look up. Look up. This silent directive matched the beat of my worn-out heart. I imagined a split screen in a movie. Kathy and I were living inside very different scenes. I was falling back in love with one of the world’s greatest cities while Kathy murdered her glowing inbox.
While we stood there, more bodies filled the piazza, and the day warmed. A school group of red-faced German teenagers loomed over a much shorter Italian guide carrying a Pantheon tour sign. Other languages written on the sign had been taped over, so only German remained, in chunky black handwriting. The teens’ shiny, sunburned skin and the odor wafting from their circle hinted at a day that had started early. The guide rattled off data about the Pantheon’s drainage system and the oculus. It is like a flashlight … a view to heaven … connection between dark and light.
One of the teens picked his nose and ate it. A bright-eyed young couple passed by, hand in hand. The woman was slender and brunette, like I’d been years ago. They walked to the café with the pink linen tablecloths. I turned to face the other side of the piazza.
A trio of women approached the area where we stood. They looked like sisters, with dark eyes, wild black hair and pale skin. They carried bags of many different colors, shapes, and sizes—purple, striped, plastic, crochet—and moved toward us with a frightening urgency.
I grabbed Kathy’s arm. “Let’s go inside,” I said, nodding at the doorway of the Pantheon.
“I’m almost done. I have to log into the portal, and I can’t remember my fucking password! Do you want to go to a cafe for a sec? I need to sit down.”
“I think—”
One of the women bumped into me, another into Kathy. All three mumbled “Scuzi” and quickly scurried away. Kathy clutched her phone and pressed it against her chest. Her other hand gripped her gold leather fanny pack, adjusted like a shield across her torso. The strap was tucked between breasts that didn’t exist in 1995.
“Gypsies!” She screamed, so loudly the German teens whipped their heads around and stared at us.
I followed the trio of women with my eyes. They snaked through a jellyfish throng of American tourists talking loudly while unsuccessfully adjusting their headset systems. Their tired guide motioned for them to keep walking.
“They’re gone,” I said with a big exhale. “Are you okay?”
She unzipped her fanny pack and rifled through her items. Her wallet, supplement packets and designer sunglasses were still there. She put her phone inside. “Ohmygod. Our first day here and it’s, like, a war zone. I’m definitely putting this in my Insta story.” She adjusted her caramel bob and dug a purple nail into a pot of lip gloss. “It’s like, why leave America?”
“This can happen anywhere,” I said.
“My heart is racing!” Kathy puckered her lips and pulled her phone out of her fanny pack again. “I’m calling Charles. My wallet’s here but, you know. Just in case they got my credit card number.”
“I don’t think they could have done that so quickly,” I said. I rummaged inside my shoulder bag and looked at Kathy. Unlike her, I could frown to illustrate distress.
“My wallet’s missing,” I said. “Shit.”
Kathy’s c’s pushed upward. “Seriously?” She unzipped her fanny pack, reconfirmed her belongings were inside, and released an orgasmic sigh. “Omygod! Thank God. My stuff is still here.”
“Right,” I said. “And mine is not.”
“Should I find the embassy?” Kathy opened Google, eager to start a new task.
“I’ll just go back to the hotel and deal with all this,” I said, using a somber tone I’d perfected over the past year. “You stay here. Go to a café and do your emails or whatever. I’ll meet you at the restaurant.”
“Good thinking. The concierge is a little slow but if you get in front of him, he has to, like, do something. You know?”
I took a deep breath, nodded, and turned. I tightened my grip on my bag as I moved.
Kathy yelled at my back. “Jane! Did you make a reservation?”
I kept walking. Beads of sweat formed on my upper lip as I retraced my steps past the tacky trinket shops and chalkboard signs and rows and rows of gelato, toward our hotel on the Aventine hill.
I put my hand in my bag, touched my wallet, and picked up my pace.
Henrietta Pertuz is a writer and nonprofit social worker. Her writing explores community, family, love and loss. She lives in New York City with her husband, three children and their beloved dog.